I just answered my own question. It appears copies are available at the New
York State Library.
From: Debra Winchell [mailto:email@example.com]
Sent: Sunday, June 09, 2013 12:57 AM
Subject: Early Settlers of New York State, Volumes I and II
I found a source of information new to me on Ancestry tonight, Early
Settlers of New York State, Their Ancestors and Descendants, Thomas Foley,
Akron, NY. It looks like it was published by Genealogical Publishing.
Ancestry provides Volumes I and II. They actually had two marriage records
I was looking for, and it gave the church (yippee!). Has anyone heard of
this before? Does anyone know if it exists in a physical form somewhere?
It's not showing up on Worldcat.
Thanks very much.