My Gr-grandmother was Anna Melissa Shufelt, from the Kinderhook, Claverack,
Mellenville, area, she was born in 1840. Another, Anna W. Shufelt, was
born March 18th, 1854. My Gr-grandmother married William Henry Chace, from
Hillsdale, I think (don't have all my notes handy), so she is not your Anna.
I don't have Anna W's marraige, so can't help there, except that my Anna and
Anna W. were related and I have lots of Shufelts from that area. If you
think this helps, please contact me. Sandi (Chace) Hutchins.