Cathy,
1-Frakes Cemetry, Leopold Twp., Spencer Co. Indiana
Carr, Mary G. 1855 - 1904 mother
Harrison W. 1839 - 1940 father
Saddler, John L. 11 Sep 1884 - 9 Oct 1926
Joseph E. 6 Jan 1903 - Jul 1905
Saddler, Justena - 20 Jan 1870 wife of John/ 43y7m6d
Saddler, John - 17 Aug 1884 consort of Justena/ 60y11m21d
2- German Ridge Cemetery, Oil Twp., Perry Co., IN
Saddler, John C. Jr. 4 Oct 1872 - 25 Jan 1915 husband of Emma A.H.
Saddler, Christopher J. 1 Jun 1873 - 5 Jul 1893 son of JC & C
Saddler, Elma A.E. 21 Sep 1875 - 5 Apr 1897 daughter of JC & Kate
Saddler, John C. 26 Jan 1845 - not carved father
Catharine 31 Dec 1849 - 22 Sep 1909 mother
Here are the 1880 Census' for Indiana that have a Mary Saddler that range
in birth from about 1851 on.
1- Perry County, Indiana, Oil Twp pg 2C
Saddler, John C self wm md 36 IN - - farmer
Katharine wife wf md 33 MD - - keeping house
Mary L. dau wf s 10 IN -- MD
John C. son wm s 8 IN -- MD
Jacob son wm s 7 IN -- MD
Elizabeth A dau wf s 4 IN -- MD
2- Putnam County, Indiana, Madison Twp 505D
Sadler, Thomas self wm md 23 IN KY KY
Mary E wife wf md 21 IN KY KY
Andrew W son wm s 2 IN IN IN
Otus E son wm s 1 IN IN IN
3- Johnson County, Indiana, Edinburg, 215 A
Saddler, J. self wm md 56 IN KY KY physician
Angeline wife wf md 43 IN PA CT keeping house
Fannie L. dau wf s 21 IN IN IN
Kate C dau wf s 19 IN IN IN
Mary dau wf s 12 IN IN IN
Horace son wm s 3 IN IN IN
4- Switzerland County, Indiana, Cotton Twp, 16A
Sadler, George self wm md 55 PA PA PA farmer
Eunice wife wf md 52 NY NY NY keeping house
John son wm s 26 IN PA NY farmer
Mary dau wf s 24 IN PA NY
Alvin son wm s 23 IN PA NY farm hand
Olive dau wf s 21 IN PA NY
George son wm s 17 IN PA NY
Martha dau wf s 14 IN PA NY
Susan dau wf w 11 IN PA NY
5- Putnam County, Indiana, Franklin Twp, pg 362D
Sadler, William self wm md 36 KY KY KY farmer
Susan wife wf md 34 KY KY KY
Mary E dau wf s 12 KY KY KY
William son wm s 10 KY KY KY
John son wm s 8 KY KY KY
Thomas H. son wm s 7 KY KY KY
James M. son wm s 6 KY KY KY
Farmer son wm s 3 KY KY KY
Albert son wm s 1 IN KY KY
Hale, William f-in-law wm md 76 KY VA VA retired farmer
6- Shelby County, Indiana, Washington Twp 372C
Sadler, Mary other fw div 31 IN Ger OH servant
Dora other fw s 18 IN Ger OH servant
(with John Nading family)
Looks kind of confusing to me, hopefully you can figure all this out.
Good luck,.
James