Beginning March 2nd, 2020 the Mailing Lists functionality on RootsWeb will be discontinued. Users will no longer be able to send outgoing emails or accept incoming emails. Additionally, administration tools will no longer be available to list administrators and mailing lists will be put into an archival state.
Administrators may save the emails in their list prior to March 2nd. After that, mailing list archives will remain available and searchable on RootsWeb
Halbert's has been discussed as unscrupulous but this article
has a lot of other such scams...
From: Eastman's Online Genealogy Newsletter, Vol. 6 No. 11-
March 12, 2001
==============================================================
- Genealogy Scams
A few years ago I wrote a number of articles about the infamous
Halberts of Bath, Ohio. This company would send an advertisement
for a book that claimed to be a "history of your family name."
After paying about $40, the hapless purchaser received a cheaply-
made paperback containing a bit of generic "how to get start
tracing your family tree information" accompanied by listings from
telephone books. Sadly, similar information was available online
at no cost.
In August 1998 I even visited the address in Bath, Ohio that
Halberts used, and I wrote about my trip in that week's edition of
this newsletter. I found no company named Halberts at that
address. In fact, the address was simply a mail drop. All orders
sent to that address in Bath, Ohio were actually forwarded to the
parent company in nearby Akron. About a year after my on-site
visit, Halberts folded up. They gave layoff notices to all of
their employees, sold the office furniture, and ceased operations.
The company blamed "competition from the Internet" for their
business failure. In my opinion, the competition was twofold: (1.)
the same information was available online at no charge, and (2.)
the Internet provides a great place for tracking such scams. Those
who received the advertisements could easily go online to check
Halberts' reputation. All you had to do was to go to any search
engine and enter the word "Halberts" to learn of the experiences
of others. In fact, you can still do that today.
Of course, Halberts was not the only company with questionable
business practices in this arena. Some of us still remember
Beatrice Bailey. This lady sold products that were somewhat
similar to those of Halberts. In her advertisement sent by mail to
me, she would sign her name as "Beatrice Eastman Bailey." In a
letter sent to someone named Smith, she would sign her name as
"Beatrice Smith Bailey" and in an advertisement sent to someone
named Williams she would sign as "Beatrice Williams Bailey."
Beatrice Bailey apparently was a one-person operation. She was
under investigation by postal authorities when she died.
Other companies have continued to sell "products" that claim to
contain genealogy value but, in fact, have little genealogy
information in them. The brave new world of the Internet has been
a haven for honest entrepreneurs and dishonest scam artists alike.
New scams have arisen and established scam artists have expanded
into online operations. As always, spending money is a case of
Caveat Emptor - "Let the buyer beware!"
There are several Web sites that track companies that sell
questionable genealogy products and services. If you have any
questions about an advertisement you received, either in regular
mail or in e-mail, I would suggest that you check the following:
Genealogy scams in general:
Genealogical Web Site Watchdog (only for online scams) at:
http://www.ancestordetective.com/watchdog.htm
The National Genealogical Society's Consumer Protection
Committee is quite active at keeping an eye on the various
scams, including both online and offline fraudsters. If you
have a question about a particular company's services, you can
contact the NGS Consumer Protection Committee via traditional
mail at: National Genealogical Society's Consumer Protection
Committee, at 4527 17th Street North, Arlington, VA 22207-
2399. The committee also maintains Web pages at:
http://www.ngsgenealogy.org/comconsumer.htm and at:
http://www.ngsgenealogy.org/comconsumerpsst.htm. However,
those pages do not mention specific companies.
Cyndi's List has a section for genealogy myths, hoaxes and
scams at: http://www.cyndislist.com/myths.htm
Specific companies:
I have received e-mail about the following companies; all have
been mentioned as having questionable services. I have listed URLs
where you can obtain further information:
Family Discovery.com - an online Web site that claims to have
"the Web's most versatile Award Winning collection of
genealogical databases." However, they don't mention the
"award" they received from the Better Business Bureau! The
Bureau says, "Based on BBB files, this company has an
unsatisfactory record with the Bureau due to unanswered
complaint(s)." Family Discovery.com charges $59.99 for a one-
year subscription. Most of the same information is available
elsewhere on the Web at no charge. In fact, many of the links
on FamilyDiscovery.com simply take you to free Web sites. You
can obtain the same information at no cost by using one of the
free search engines. Details are available on the Genealogical
Web Site Watchdog site at:
http://www.ancestordetective.com/watchdog.htm#Warning. There
is an Anti-FamilyDiscovery.com newsletter at:
http://compuright.dyndns.org/familydiscovery/
The xxx Family Yearbook - In this case, substitute your last
name for the "xxx." For instance, an advertisement sent to a
person named Smith would be advertising The Smith Family
Yearbook while someone named Clark would receive an
advertisement for The Clark Family Yearbook. These "yearbooks"
claim to have genealogy information. However, those who
purchase the "products" are usually disappointed. The
producing company has several business names; for example, you
can find them listed as Mountain West News Service or as the
Mountain Pacific News Service. They also may appear as an
organizational name, such as "The Smith Family Yearbook."
However, all these "companies" have the same address: 1181 S.
Parker Road, #105, Denver, CO 80231. The Better Business
Bureau lists the parent company as MORPHCORP. The News Herald
of Panama City, Florida has an article about these "products"
at: http://www.newsherald.com/articles/2000/04/16/tp041600.htm
Family Tree House - I wrote about this company in the October
31, 1998 edition of this newsletter. The company gives an
appearance of a Web site that offers genealogy services. In
fact, it does not appear to sell anything. However, the same
company advertises on another Web site with an offer to sell
personal information obtained from genealogists who visit the
Family Tree House site. You innocently enter personal
information about yourself on Family Tree House and then
operators of the site sell your personal information to bulk
mail companies. Information for sale includes name, address,
e-mail address and more. You can read that article at:
http://ancestordetective.com/watchdog.htm#sells
The Historical Research Center (HRC) International, Inc. sells
"family histories" and coats of arms. Information about the
true value of these products can be found on the Genealogical
Web Site Watchdog site at:
http://www.ancestordetective.com/watchdog.htm#Coats. Keep
in mind that this company sells franchises. A few years ago
they were listed as one of the top 30 fastest growing
franchises in America. You may find their products being sold
by other companies who purchase franchises. One such company
is Names.com, but apparently there are many others as well.
The International Hall of Names in Canada also sells "family
histories" and coats of arms. They are also mentioned on the
Genealogical Web Site Watchdog site at:
http://www.ancestordetective.com/watchdog.htm#Coats.
I would caution anyone to be careful about "family coats of arms."
In fact, in England, Wales, Scotland, Ireland, and most of western
Europe, there really is no such thing as a family coat of arms. In
those countries, arms have always been awarded to individuals, not
to families. Displaying a coat of arms that you are not authorized
to use is a form of identity theft, even if you do happen to have
the same last name as the original grantee. Any company offering
to sell you a copy of "your family's coat of arms" is selling a
bogus product.
If you believe you have been the victim of a genealogy scam, you
can do something about it! If you purchased products or services
from the above companies or any others that you feel did not live
up to advertised claims, demand a refund! If your money is not
returned within 30 days or so from a U.S. company, submit a
complaint to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Bureau of Consumer
Protection at:
https://rn.ftc.gov/dod/wsolcq$.startup?Z_ORG_CODE=PU01. A few
letters of inquiry from the federal government will send a strong
message to the people who produce products or services of
questionable value. If a Canadian company is involved, you can
register a complaint at:
http://strategis.ic.gc.ca/SSG/ct01250e.html.
You also might want to warn other genealogists and tell them of
your experiences. You can post a message to others in the "Scams
and Fraud" section of CompuServe's Genealogy Techniques Forum
message board. Go to:
http://forums.compuserve.com/vlforums/default.asp?SRV=GenealogyForum&AREA=Ms
gs&SEC=15&loc=us&a
ccess=public
==============================================================
Later...Nancy
List Admin
COUNTRYMAN-L, LETSON-L, SACKETT-L and SIDERS-L