Could I suggest New Lyme, Ashtabula County, Ohio as a place to look for
William's birth as the Champions were migrated that way from Lyme, New
London, Connecticut. Other surnames migrating with them were Randall,
Huntley, Peck and Brockway. Have you tried <familysearch.org>? or GenForum?
My Champion surname was disguised by marriage in Ashtabula. Finding it again
in Walker was confirmation of the earlier marriage...I am glad it helped you.
I will keep the Nutter name in mind. I don't think that was strictly a
Catholic cemetery back at the time of those burials.
Claudia Day
Grand Rapids, Michigan