This is a Message Board Post that is gatewayed to this mailing list.
Author: Marcine_Lohman
Surnames: CARSON, HAMPTON, ROBINSON
Classification: queries
Message Board URL:
http://boards.rootsweb.com/surnames.carson/2762/mb.ashx
Message Board Post:
When I find identified photos on eBay, I like to post them on related message boards for
possible relatives. The attached photo is identified below.
American Frontiersman & Old West Legend, Kit Carson
Christopher Houston "Kit" Carson (December 24, 1809 - May 23, 1868) was an
American frontiersman. Carson left home at an early age and became a trapper. He gained
notoriety for his role as John C. Fremont's guide in the American West. Carson also
played a minor role in California during the 1846-48 Mexican-American War, and later
became a rancher in New Mexico. During the American Civil War, he helped organize the New
Mexico volunteer infantry, and fought against Navajo natives, against his will, but by
order of the U.S. Army. By 1864, about 8000 Navajo had surrendered to the U.S. Army, while
another 8000 hid in the back country. Kit Carson finally went home to his family. After
the Civil War, Carson moved to Colorado, where he died.
Early life
Born in Madison County, Kentucky, near the city of Richmond, Carson was raised in a rural
area near Franklin, Missouri (Pacific, MO use to be called Franklin - is this the same
town?), where his family moved in 1811, when Kit was about one year old. Carson's
father, Lindsey Carson, was a farmer of Scots-Irish descent, who had fought in the
Revolutionary War under General Wade Hampton. There were a total of 15 Carson children:
five by Lindsey Carson's first wife, and ten by Kit's mother, Rebecca Robinson.
Kit was the eleventh child in the family. The Carson family settled on a tract of land
owned by the sons of Daniel Boone, who had purchased the land from the Spanish prior to
the Louisiana Purchase. The Boone and Carson families became good friends, working,
socializing, and intermarrying.
Carson was eight years old when his father was killed by a falling tree while clearing
land. Lindsey Carson's death reduced the Carson family to a desperate poverty, forcing
young Kit to drop out of school to work on the family farm, as well as engage in hunting.
At age 14, Kit was apprenticed to a saddlemaker (Workman's Saddleshop) in the
settlement of Franklin, Missouri. Franklin was situated at the eastern end of the Santa Fe
Trail, which had opened two years earlier. Many of the clientele at the saddleshop were
trappers and traders, from whom Kit would hear their stirring tales of the Far West.
Carson is reported to have found work in the saddle shop suffocating: he once stated
"the business did not suit me, and I concluded to leave". His Master may have
agreed with his leaving since he offered the odd amount of 1 cent for his return and
waited a month to post the notice in the local newspaper.
At sixteen, Carson secretly signed on with a large merchant caravan heading to Santa Fe;
his job was to tend the horses, mules, and oxen. During the winter of 1826-1827 he stayed
with Matthew Kinkead, a trapper and explorer, in Taos, New Mexico, then known as the
capital of the fur trade in the Southwest. Kinkead had been a friend of Carson's
father in Missouri, and he taught Carson the skills of a trapper. Carson also began
learning the necessary languages and became fluent in Spanish, Navajo, Apache, Cheyenne,
Arapaho, Paiute, Shoshone, and Ute.
The trapper years (1829-40)
After gaining experience along the Santa Fe Trail and in Mexico, Carson signed on with a
trapping party of forty men, led by Ewing Young in the Spring of 1829; this was
Carson's first official expedition as a trapper. The journey took the band into
unexplored Apache country along the Gila River. Ewing's group was approached and
attacked by Apache natives. It was during this encounter that Carson shot and killed one
of the attacking Apache, the first time he killed a man.
At the age of 25, in the summer of 1835, Carson attended an annual mountain man
rendezvous, which was held along the Green River in southwestern Wyoming. He became
interested in an Arapaho woman whose name, Waa-Nibe, is approximated in English as
"Singing Grass" Her tribe was camped nearby the rendezvous. Singing Grass is
said to have been popular at the rendezvous and also to have caught the attention of a
French-Canadian trapper, Joseph Chouinard. When Singing Grass chose Carson over Chouinard,
the rejected suitor became belligerent. Chouinard is reported to have disrupted the camp,
so that Carson could no longer tolerate the situation. Words were exchanged, and Carson
and Chouinard charged each other on horses, brandishing their weapons. Carson blew off the
thumb of his opponent with his pistol, while Chouinard's rifle shot barely missed,
grazing Carson below his left ear and scorching his eye and hair. Carson stated that had
his opponent's horse not shied as he fired, Ch!
ouinard might have finished him off, as he was a splendid shot.
Controversy regarding Chouinard's fate continues, with no certainty achieved. The duel
with Chouinard is said to have made Carson famous among the mountain men but was also
considered uncharacteristic of him.
Carson considered his years as a trapper to be "the happiest days of my life."
Accompanied by Singing Grass, he worked with the Hudson's Bay Company, as well as the
renowned frontiersman Jim Bridger, trapping beaver along the Yellowstone, Powder, and Big
Horn Rivers, and was found throughout what is now Colorado, Utah, Wyoming, Idaho, and
Montana. Carson's first child, a daughter named Adeline, was born in 1837. Singing
Grass gave birth to a second daughter and developed a fever shortly after the child's
birth, and died sometime between 1838-40.
At this time, the nation was undergoing a severe depression (see Panic of 1837). The fur
industry was undermined by changing fashion styles: a new demand for silk hats replaced
the demand for beaver fur. Also, the trapping industry had devastated the beaver
population; this combination of facts ended the need for trappers. Carson stated,
"Beaver was getting scarce, it became necessary to try our hand at something
else."
He attended the last mountain man rendezvous, held in the summer of 1840 (again at Ft.
Bridger near the Green River) and moved on to Bent's Fort, finding employment as a
hunter. Carson married a Cheyenne woman, Making-Our-Road, in 1841 but Making-Our-Road left
him only a short time later to follow her tribe's migration. By 1842 he met and became
engaged to the daughter of a prominent Taos family: Josefa Jaramillo. After receiving
instruction from Padre Antonio José Martínez, he was baptized into the Catholic Church in
1842. When he was 34, he married 14-year-old Josefa, his third wife, on February 6, 1843.
They raised eight children, the descendants of whom remain in the Arkansas Valley of
Colorado.
Guide with Fremont (1842-1846)
Carson decided early in 1842 to return east to bring his daughter Adeline to live with
relatives near Carson's former home of Franklin, for the purpose of providing her with
an education. That summer he met John C. Frémont on a Missouri River steamboat in
Missouri. Frémont was preparing to lead his first expedition and was looking for a guide
to take him to South Pass. The two men made acquaintance, and Carson offered his services,
as he had spent much time in the area. The five month journey, made with 25 men, was a
success, and Fremont's report was published by Congress. His report "touched off
a wave of wagon caravans filled with hopeful emigrants" heading West.
Frémont's success in the first expedition led to his second expedition, undertaken in
the summer of 1843, which proposed to map and describe the second half of the Oregon
Trail, from South Pass to the Columbia River. Due to his proven skill as a guide in the
first expedition, Carson's services were again requested. This journey took them along
the Great Salt Lake into Oregon, establishing all the land in the Great Basin to be
land-locked, which contributed greatly to the understanding of North American geography at
the time. Their trip brought them into sight of Mount Rainier, Mount Saint Helens, and
Mount Hood.
One purpose of this expedition had been to locate the Buenaventura, a major east-west
river that was believed to connect the Great Lakes with the Pacific Ocean. Though its
existence was accepted as scientific fact at the time, it was not to be found.
Frémont's second expedition established that this mystical river was a fable.
The second expedition became snowbound in the Sierra Nevadas that winter, and was in
danger of mass starvation. Carson's wilderness expertise pulled them through, in spite
of being half-starved. Food was scarce enough that their mules "ate one another's
tails and the leather of the pack saddles."
The expedition moved south into the Mojave Desert, enduring attacks by Natives, which
killed one man. Also, when the expedition had crossed into California, they had officially
invaded Mexico. The threat of military intervention by that country sent Fremont's
expedition further southeast, into Nevada, at a watering hole known as Las Vegas. The
party traveled on to Bent's Fort, and by August, 1844 returned to Washington, over a
year after their departure. Another Congressional report on Fremont's expedition was
published. By the time of the second report in 1845, Frémont and Carson were becoming
nationally famous.
Somewhere along this route, Frémont and party came across a Mexican man and a boy who were
survivors of an ambush by a band of Natives, who had killed two men, staked two women to
the ground and mutilated them, and stolen 30 horses. Carson and fellow mountain man Alex
Godey took pity on the two survivors. They tracked the Native band for 2 days, and upon
locating them, rushed into their encampment. They killed two Native Americans, scattered
the rest, and returned with the horses.
"More than any other single factor or incident, [the Mojave Desert incident] from
Frémont's second expedition report is where the Kit Carson legend was born....."
On June 1, 1845 John Frémont and 55 men left St. Louis, with Carson as guide, on the third
expedition. The stated goal was to "map the source of the Arkansas River", on
the east side of the Rocky Mountains. But upon reaching the Arkansas, Frémont suddenly
made a hasty trail straight to California, without explanation. Arriving in the Sacramento
Valley in early winter 1846, he promptly sought to stir up patriotic enthusiasm among the
American settlers there. He promised that if war with Mexico started, his military force
would "be there to protect them." Frémont nearly provoked a battle with General
José Castro near Monterey, which would have likely resulted in the annihilation of
Frémont's group, due to the superior numbers of the Mexican troops. Frémont then fled
Mexican-controlled California, and went north to Oregon, finding camp at Klamath L
On the night of May 9, 1846 Frémont received a courier, Lieutenant Archibald Gillespie,
who brought him messages from President James Polk. Frémont stayed up late reviewing these
messages and neglected to post a watchman for the camp, as was customary for security
measures. The neglect of this action is said to have been troubling to Carson, yet he had
"apprehended no danger". Later that night Carson was awakened by the sound of a
thump. Jumping up, he saw his friend and fellow trapper Basil Lajeunesse sprawled in
blood. He called an alarm and immediately everyone else came to: they were under attack by
Native Americans estimated to be several dozen in number. By the time the assailants were
beaten off, two other members of Frémonts group were dead. The one dead warrior was judged
to be a Klamath Lake Native. Frémont's group fell into "an angry gloom."
Carson was beside himself, and Frémont reports he smashed away at the dead warrior's
face until it was pu
To avenge the deaths of his expedition members, Frémont chose to attack a Klamath Tribe
fishing village named Dokdokwas, at the junction of the Williamson River and Klamath Lake,
which took place May 10, 1846. Accounts by scholars vary as to what happened but it is
certain that the action completely destroyed the village. Carson was nearly killed by a
Klamath warrior later that day: his gun misfired, and the warrior drew to shoot a poison
arrow; but Frémont, seeing Carson's predicament, trampled the warrior with his horse.
Carson stated he felt that he owed Frémont his life due to this incident
"The tragedy of Dokdokwas is deepened by the fact that most scholars now agree that
Frémont and Carson, in their blind vindictiveness, probably chose the wrong tribe to lash
out against: In all likelihood the band of native Americans that had killed [Frémont's
three men] were from the neighboring Modocs....The Klamaths were culturally related to the
Modocs, but the two tribes were bitter enemies."
Turning south from Klamath Lake, Frémont led his expedition back down the Sacramento
Valley, and slyly promoted an insurrection of American settlers, which he then took charge
of once circumstances had adequately developed, known as the Bear Flag Revolt. Events
escalated when a group of Mexicans murdered two American rebels. Frémont imprisoned José
de los Santos Berreyesa, the alcalde, or mayor of Sonoma, two other Berreyesa brothers,
and others he felt were involved. On June 28, 1846, Berreyesa's father, José de los
Reyes Berreyesa, crossed the San Francisco Bay and landed near San Quentin with two
cousins, twin sons of Francisco de Haro, intending to visit his sons in jail. Frémont
ordered Carson and two others to execute the three Californios. Later, Carson told Jasper
O'Farrell that he regretted killing the men, but that the act was only one such that
Frémont ordered him to com
Mexican American War service
Frémont's California Battalion next moved south to the provincial capital of Monterey,
California, and met Commodore Robert Stockton there in mid-July 1846. Stockton had sailed
into harbor with two American warships and taken claim to Monterey for the United States.
Learning that the war with Mexico was underway, Stockton made plans to capture Los Angeles
and San Diego and proceed on to Mexico City. He joined forces with Frémont, and made
Carson a lieutenant, thus initiating Carson's military career.
Frémont's unit arrived in San Diego on one of Stockton's ships on July 29, 1846,
and took over the town without resistance. Stockton, traveling on a separate warship,
claimed Santa Barbara a few days later. (See Mission Santa Barbara and Presidio of Santa
Barbara). Meeting up and joining forces in San Diego, they marched to Los Angeles and
claimed this town without any challenge, and Stockton declared California to be United
States territory on August 17, 1846. The following day, August 18, Stephen W. Kearny rode
into Santa Fe, New Mexico with his Army of the West and declared the New Mexican territory
conquered.
Stockton and Frémont were eager to announce the conquest of California to President Polk,
and wished for Carson to carry their correspondence overland to the President. Carson
accepted the mission, and pledged to cross the continent within 60 days. He left Los
Angeles with 15 men and 6 Delaware natives on September 5.
Service with Kearny
Thirty one days later on October 6, Carson chanced to meet Kearny and his 300 dragoons at
the deserted village of Valverde. Kearny was under orders from the Polk Administration to
subdue both New Mexico and California, and set up governments there. Learning that
California was already conquered, he sent 200 of his men back to Santa Fe, and ordered
Carson to guide him back to California so he could stabilize the situation there. Kearny
sent the mail on to Washington by another courier.
For the next six weeks, Lt. Carson guided Kearny and the 100 dragoons west along the Gila
River over very rugged terrain, arriving at the Colorado River on November 25. On some
parts of the trail mules died at a rate of almost 12 a day. By December 5, three months
after leaving Los Angeles, Carson had brought Kearny's men to within 25 miles (40 km)
of their destination, San Diego.
A Mexican courier was captured en route to Sonora Mexico carrying letters to General Jose
Castro that reported a Mexican revolt which had recaptured California from Commodore
Stockton: all the coastal cities now were back under Mexican control, except for San
Diego, where the Mexicans had Stockton pinned down and under siege. Kearny was himself in
perilous danger, as his force was reduced both in numbers and in a state of physical
exhaustion: they had to come out of the Gila River trail and confront the Mexican forces,
or risk perishing in the desert.
The Battle of San Pasqual
While approaching San Diego, Kearny sent a rancher ahead to notify Commodore Stockton of
his presence. The rancher, Edward Stokes, returned with 39 American troops and information
that several hundred Mexican dragoons under Capt Andres Pico were camped at the indigenous
village of San Pasqual, lying on the route between him and Stockton. Kearny decided to
raid Pico in order to capture fresh horses, and sent out a scouting party on the night of
December 5-6.
The scouting party encountered a barking dog in San Pasqual, and Captain Pico's troops
were aroused from their sleep. Having been detected, Kearny decided to attack, and
organized his troops to advance on San Pasqual. A complex battle evolved, where twenty-one
Americans were killed and many more wounded: many from the long lances of the Mexican
caballeros, who also displayed expert horsemanship. By the end of the second day, December
7, the Americans were nearly out of food and water, low on ammunition and weak from the
journey along the Gila River. They faced starvation and possible annihilation by the
Mexican troops who vastly outnumbered them, and Kearny ordered his men to dig in on top of
a small hill.
Kearny then sent Carson and two other men to slip through the siege and get
reinforcements. Carson, Edward Beale, and a native American left on the night of December
8 for San Diego which was 25 miles (40 km) away. Because their canteens made too much
noise, they were left along the path. Because their boots also made too much noise, Carson
and Beale removed these and tucked them under their belts. These they lost, and Carson and
Beale traveled the distance to San Diego barefoot through desert, rock, and cactus.
By December 10, Kearny had decided all hope was gone, and planned to attempt a breakout
the next morning: but that night, 200 American troops on fresh horses arrived, the Mexican
army dispersed with the new show of strength. Kearny was able to arrive in San Diego by
December 12. This action contributed to the prompt reconquest of California by the
American forces.
Civil War and Indian Activity
Following the recapture of Los Angeles in 1846, Frémont was appointed Governor of
California by Commodore Stockton. Frémont sent Carson to carry messages back to Washington
City. He stopped in St. Louis and met with Senator Thomas Benton, who was a prominent
supporter of the settling of the West and a proponent of Manifest Destiny, and had been
prominent in getting Frémont's expedition reports published by Congress. Once in
Washington, Carson delivered his messages to Secretary of State James Buchanan, as well as
had meetings with Secretary of War William Marcy and President James Polk
Having completed this mission, Carson received orders to do it all again: return to
California with messages, receive further messages there, and bring those back yet again
to Washington. By the end of the Frémont expeditions and these courier missions, Carson
felt he wanted to settle down with Joséfa, and decided in 1849 to go into farming in
Taos.
Carson's public image as an action hero had been sealed by the Frémont expedition
reports of 1845. In 1849, the first of many Carson action novels appeared. The first,
written by Charles Averill, bore the name Kit Carson: The Prince of the Gold Hunters. This
type of western pulp fiction was known as "blood and thunders." In Averill's
novel, Carson finds a kidnapped girl and rescues her, after having vowed to her distraught
parents in Boston that he would scour the American West until she was found.
This book was among the possessions Carson and Major William Grier found when they
recovered the body of Mrs. Ann White in November, 1849. Mrs. White and her daughter had
been taken captive by Jicarilla Apaches several weeks earlier. She had been traveling with
her husband James White, a trader, to Santa Fe, when a group of native Americans
approached them as they camped along the Santa Fe trail. Mr. White tried to disperse the
natives with his rifle, but they attacked, killing everyone except Mrs. White, her
daughter, and a servant.
Carson and Grier tracked the natives for twelve days to their camp on the Canadian River.
Carson wanted an immediate attack, while Grier wanted to parlay with the Jicarillas. The
disagreement in tactics caused delay, which gave the natives time to disperse from camp
and escape. In the process, Mrs. White appears to have attempted to flee and was killed by
an arrow through the heart.
While picking through the belongings that the Jicarillas had left in their camp, one of
Major Grier's soldiers came across a book that the White family had carried with them
from Missouri: the paperback novel starring Kit Carson. This book must have been shown to
him, for he was to comment on it later. This was the first time that the real Kit Carson
came in contact with his own myth.
The episode of the White massacre haunted Carson's memory for many years. He once
stated, "I have often thought that, as Mrs. White read the book, she prayed for my
appearance, knowing that I lived nearby." His fear was that the book had given her a
false hope. He wrote later, "I have much regretted the failure to save the life of so
esteemed a lady." He was troubled by the implications and false image that developed
around his celebrity status.
On the 22nd January (1858), Kit Carson concluded a treaty of peace between the Muatche
Utahs, the Arapahoes, and the Pueblos of Taos. They agree to take side with the United
States in the event of any issue between them and the people of any Territory, and do what
they can for the suppression of rebellion in Utah. Fears were entertained at one time that
the Muatche Utahs were in alliance with the Mormons. -New York Tribune, March 23, 1858, p.
1, column 6.
When the American Civil War began in April 1861, Kit Carson resigned his post as federal
Indian agent for northern New Mexico and joined the New Mexico volunteer infantry which
was being organized by Ceran St. Vrain. Although New Mexico Territory officially allowed
slavery, geography and economics made the institution so impractical that there were only
a handful of slaves within its boundaries. The territorial government and the leaders of
opinion all threw their support to the Union.
Overall command of Union forces in the Department of New Mexico fell to Colonel Edward R.
S. Canby of the Regular Army's 19th Infantry, headquartered at Ft. Marcy in Santa Fe.
Carson, with the rank of Colonel of Volunteers, commanded the third of five columns in
Canby's force. Carson's command was divided into two battalions each made up of
four companies of the First New Mexico Volunteers, in all some 500 men.
Early in 1862, Confederate forces in Texas under General Henry Hopkins Sibley undertook an
invasion of New Mexico Territory. The goal of this expedition was to conquer the rich
Colorado gold fields and redirect this valuable resource from the North to the South.
Advancing up the Rio Grande, Sibley's command clashed with Canby's Union force at
Valverde on February 21, 1862. The day-long Battle of Valverde ended when the Confederates
captured a Union battery of six guns and forced the rest of Canby's troops back across
the river with losses of 68 killed and 160 wounded. Colonel Carson's column spent the
morning on the west side of the river out of the action, but at 1 p.m., Canby ordered them
to cross, and Carson's battalions fought until ordered to retreat. Carson lost one man
killed and one wounded.
Colonel Canby had little or no confidence in the hastily recruited, untrained New Mexico
volunteers, "who would not obey orders or obeyed them too late to be of any
service." In his battle report, however, he did commend Carson, among other volunteer
officers, for his "zeal and energy."
After the battle at Valverde, Colonel Canby and most of the regular troops were ordered to
the eastern front, but Carson and his New Mexico Volunteers were fully occupied by
"Indian troubles."
Prelude to the Navajo campaign
Contact between the Navajo and the U.S. Army was prompted by a Navajo raid on Socorro, New
Mexico near the end of September, 1846. General Kearny, passing nearby on his way to
California after his recent conquest of Santa Fe, learned of the raid and sent a note to
Col. William Doniphan, his second in command in Santa Fe. He asked Doniphan to send a
regiment of soldiers into Navajo country and secure a peace treaty with them.
A detachment of 30 men made contact with the Navajo and spoke to the Navajo Chief Narbona
in mid-October, about the same time that Carson met Gen. Kearny on the trail to
California. A second meeting with Chief Narbona and Col. Doniphan occurred several weeks
later. Doniphan informed the Navajo that all their land now belonged to the United States,
and the Navajo and New Mexicans were now the "children of the United States." In
spite of this, the Navajo signed a treaty, known as the Bear Spring treaty, on November
21, 1846. The treaty forbade the Navajo to raid or make war on the New Mexicans, but
allowed the New Mexicans the privilege of making war on the Navajo if they saw fit.
Despite the treaty, raiding continued in New Mexico by the Navajo, as well as the
Jicarilla Apache, Mescalero Apache, Ute, Comanche, and Kiowa. On August 16, 1849 the U.S.
Army began an expedition into the heart of Navajo country on an organized reconnaissance
for the purpose of impressing the Navajo with the might of the U.S. military, and to map
the terrain for further operations and to plan forts. The expedition was led by Col. John
Washington, the military governor of New Mexico at the time. The expedition included
nearly a thousand infantry (U.S. and New Mexican volunteers), hundreds of horses and
mules, a supply train, 55 native Pueblo scouts, and four artillery guns.
On August 29-30, 1849, Washington's expedition was in need of water, and began
pillaging Navajo cornfields. It became clear the Navajo intended to resist further
pillaging, with mounted warriors darting back and forth around Washington's troops. It
is further documented that Washington's reasoning was that the pillaging of Navajo
crops was justified because the Navajo would have to reimburse the U.S. government for the
cost of the expedition.
In this setting, Washington was still able to communicate to the Navajo that in spite of
the hostile situation, they and the whites could "still be friends if the Navajo came
with their chiefs the next day and signed a treaty." This is in fact exactly what the
Navajo did.
The next day Chief Narbona came once again to "talk peace," along with several
other headmen. An accord was reached on nearly every matter. When a New Mexican thought he
saw his stolen horse and the Navajo protested its return, a scuffle broke out. (The Navajo
position was that the horse had passed through several owners by this time, and now
rightfully belonged to its Navajo owner). Col. Washington sided with the New Mexican.
Since the Navajo owner now took his horse and fled the scene, Washington told the New
Mexican to go pick out any Navajo horse he wanted. The rest of the Navajo present figured
out what was happening, and turned and fled. At this, Col. Washington ordered his soldiers
to fire.
Seven Navajo were killed in the volleys; the rest ran and could not be caught. One of the
dying was Chief Narbona, who was scalped as he lay dying by a New Mexican souvenir hunter.
This massacre prompted the warlike Navajo leaders such as Manuelito to gain influence over
those who were advocates of peace.
Carson's Navajo campaign
Raiding by native Americans had been rather constant up through 1862, and New Mexicans
were becoming more outspoken in their demand that something be done. Col. Canby devised a
plan for the removal of the Navajo to a distant reservation and sent his plans to his
superiors in Washington D.C. But that year, Canby was promoted to general and recalled
back east for other duties. His replacement as commander of the Federal District of New
Mexico was Brigadier General James H. Carleton.
Carleton believed that the Navajo conflict was the reason for New Mexico's
"depressing backwardness." He naturally turned to Kit Carson to help him fulfill
his plans of upgrading New Mexico and his own career: Carson was nationally known and had
helped boost the careers of a series of military commanders who had employed him.
Carleton saw a way to harness the anxieties that had been stirred up [in New Mexico] by
the Confederate invasion and the still-hovering fear that the Texans might return. If the
territory was already on a war footing, the whole society alert and inflamed, then why not
direct all this ramped up energy toward something useful? Carleton immediately declared a
state of martial law, with curfews and mandatory passports for travel, and then brought
all his newly streamlined authority to bear on cleaning up the Navajo mess. With a focus
that bordered on obsession, he was determined finally to make good on Kearny's old
promise that the United States would "correct all this."
Furthermore, Carleton believed there was gold in the Navajo's country, and felt they
should be driven out in order to allow the development of this possibility. The immediate
prelude to Carleton's Navajo campaign was to force the Mescalero Apache to Bosque
Redondo. Carleton ordered Carson to kill all the men of that tribe, and say that he
(Carson) had been sent to "punish them for their treachery and crimes."
Carson was appalled by this brutal attitude and refused to obey it. He accepted the
surrender of more than a hundred Mescalero warriors who sought refuge with him.
Nonetheless, he completed his campaign in a month.
When Carson learned that Carleton intended for him to pursue the Navajo he sent Carleton a
letter of resignation dated February 3, 1863. Carleton refused to accept this and used the
force of his personality to maintain Carson's cooperation. In language that was
similar to his description of the Mescalero Apache, Carleton ordered Carson to lead an
expedition against the Navajo, and to say to them, "You have deceived us too often,
and robbed and murdered our people too long, to trust you again at large in your own
country. This war shall be pursued against you if it takes years, now that we have begun,
until you cease to exist or move. There can be no other talk on the subject."
Under Carleton's direction, Carson instituted a scorched earth policy, burning Navajo
fields, and homes, and confiscating or killing their livestock. Carson did not cut down
any orchard trees. He was aided by other native American tribes with long-standing enmity
toward the Navajos, chiefly the Utes. Carson was pleased with the work the Utes did for
him, but they went home early in the campaign when told they could not confiscate Navajo
booty.
Carson also had difficulty with his New Mexico volunteers. Troopers deserted and officers
resigned. Carson urged Carleton to accept two resignations he was forwarding, "as I
do not wish to have any officer in my command who is not contented or willing to put up
with as much inconvenience and privations for the success of the expedition as I undergo
myself."
There were no pitched battles and only a few skirmishes in the Navajo campaign. Carson
rounded up and took prisoner every Navajo he could find. In January 1864, Carson sent a
company into Canyon de Chelly to investigate the last Navajo stronghold, presuming them to
be under the leadership of Manuelito. The Navajo surrendered because of the confiscation
of their livestock and food supplies. In the spring of 1864, 8,000 Navajo men, women and
children were forced to march or ride in wagons 300 miles (480 km) to Fort Sumner, New
Mexico. Navajos call this "The Long Walk." Although Carson had ridden home
before the march began, he was held responsible by some Navajo for breaking his word that
those who surrendered would not be harmed. As many as 300 died along the way, and many
more during the next four years on the reservation. In 1868, after signing a treaty with
the U.S. government, these Navajos were allowed to return to a reduced area of their
homeland, where the greatly enla!
rged Navajo Reservation exists today. Thousands of other Navajo who had been living in
the wilderness returned to the Navajo homeland centered around Canyon de Chelly.
Southern Plains campaign
In November 1864, Carson was sent by General Carleton to deal with the Natives in western
Texas. Carson and his troopers met a combined force of Kiowa, Comanche, and Cheyenne
numbering over 1,500 at the ruins of Adobe Walls. In what is known as the Battle of Adobe
Walls, the Native force led by Dohäsan made several assaults on Carson's forces which
were supported by two mountain howitzers. Carson inflicted heavy losses on the attacking
warriors before burning the natives' camp and lodges and returning to Fort Bascom.
A few days later, Colonel John M. Chivington led U.S. troops in a massacre at Sand Creek.
Chivington boasted that he had surpassed Carson and would soon be known as the great
Indian killer. Carson was outraged at the massacre and openly denounced Chivington's
actions.
The Southern Plains campaign led the Comanches to sign the Little Rock Treaty of 1865. In
October 1865, General Carleton recommended that Carson be awarded the brevet rank of
brigadier general, "for gallantry in the battle of Valverde, and for distinguished
conduct and gallantry in the wars against the Mescalero Apaches and against the Navajo
natives of New Mexico."
Colorado
When the Civil War ended, and with the native American campaigns successfully concluded,
Carson left the army and took up ranching, finally settling in Boggsville, Colorado (near
the current Las Animas on the Purgatory River).
Carson died at age 58 from an abdominal aortic aneurysm in the surgeon's quarters in
Fort Lyon, Colorado, located east of Las Animas. He is buried in Taos, New Mexico,
alongside his wife, Josefa ("Josephine"), who died a month earlier of
complications following child birth. His headstone inscription reads: "Kit Carson /
Died May 23, 1868 / Aged 59 Years."
His last words were: "Adios Compadres."
Reputation
Many general accounts of Kit Carson describe him as an outstanding honorable person.
Albert Richardson, who knew him personally in the 1850s, wrote that Kit Carson was "a
gentleman by instinct, upright, pure, and simple-hearted, beloved alike by Indians,
Mexicans, and Americans".
Oscar Lipps also presented a positive image of Carson in 1909: "The name of Kit
Carson is to this day held in reverence by all the old members of the Navajo tribe. They
say he knew how to be just and considerate as well as how to fight the Indians".
Carson's contributions to western history have been reexamined by historians,
journalists and Native American activists since the 1960s. In 1968, Carson biographer
Harvey L. Carter stated:
In respect to his actual exploits and his actual character, however, Carson was not
overrated. If history has to single out one person from among the Mountain Men to receive
the admiration of later generations, Carson is the best choice. He had far more of the
good qualities and fewer of the bad qualities than anyone else in that varied lot of
individuals.
Some journalists and authors during the last 25 years presented alternate views of Kit
Carson. For instance, Virginia Hopkins stated in 1988 that "Kit Carson was directly
or indirectly responsible for the deaths of thousands of Indians". Her viewpoint is
contested by Tom Dunlay, who wrote in 2000 that Carson was directly responsible for less
than fifty deaths of indigenous and that, as Carson was not there at the time, Indian
deaths on the Long Walk or at Ft. Sumner were the responsibility of the United States Army
and General James Carleton.
Ed Quillen, publisher of Colorado Central magazine and columnist for The Denver Post,
wrote that "Carson...betrayed [the Navajo], starved them by destroying their farms
and livestock in Canyon de Chelly and then brutally marched them to the Bosque Redondo
concentration camp". In historical fact, not only was Kit Carson not involved with
'the Long Walk', a few of the natives who made that journey were riding in wagons
or riding behind U. S. Soldiers on horseback. In 1970, Lawrence Kelly noted that Carleton
had warned 18 Navajo chiefs that all Navajo peoples "must come in and go to the
Bosque Redondo where they would be fed and protected until the war was over. That unless
they were willing to do this they would be considered hostile". Quillen's
contention that Bosque Redondo was a concentration camp has been challenged. For instance,
several men went off the reservation and stole 1,000 horses from the native Comanche
people to the east.
On January 19, 2006, Marley Shebala, senior news reporter and photographer for Navajo
Times, quoted the Fort Defiance Chapter of the Navajo Nation as saying, "Carson
ordered his soldiers to shoot any Navajo, including women and children, on sight."
This view of Carson's actions may be from General James Carleton's orders to
Carson on October 12, 1862, concerning the Mescalero Apaches: "All Indian men of that
tribe are to be killed whenever and wherever you can find them: the women and children
will not be harmed, but you will take them prisoners and feed them at Ft. Stanton until
you receive other instructions".
Hampton Sides stated that Carson felt the Native Americans needed reservations as a way of
physically separating and shielding them from white hostility and white culture. Carson
believed most of the Indian troubles in the West were caused by "aggressions on the
part of whites." He is said to have viewed the raids on white settlements as driven
by desperation, "committed from absolute necessity when in a starving
condition." Native American hunting grounds were disappearing as waves of white
settlers filled the region.
In 1868, at the urging of Washington and the Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Carson
journeyed to Washington D.C. where he personally escorted several Ute Chiefs to meet with
the President of the United States to plea for assistance to their tribe.
Popular culture
The legend of Kit Carson began before he died, and has continued to grow through the years
through dime novels, poems, music, movies, television, and comic books. These fictional
tales tend to portray Carson as a heroic figure slaughtering two bears and a dozen native
Americans before breakfast, and when mixed with a few real historic events, the result is
that Kit Carson becomes larger than life.
Novels
There are at least 25 titles that have been recorded, from Kit Carson, Prince of the Gold
Hunters (1849) through Kit Carson, King of Scouts (1923).
There is also a children's novel, Adaline Falling Star (2000), by Mary Pope Osborne. a
fictional story based on Adaline, his daughter from his first marriage, who he left with
his family in Missouri during the Fremont expeditions. Carson appears at the beginning and
end of the book.
Kit Carson is included in a number of 20th century novels and pulp magazine stories:
Comanche Chaser by Dane Coolidge, On Sweet Water Trail by Sabra Conner, On to Oregon by H.
W. Morrow, The Pioneers by C. R. Cooper, The Long Trail by J. Allan Dunn and Peltry by H.
D. H. Smith.
Kit Carson also appears in historical fiction novel Flashman and the Redskins by George
MacDonald Fraser, where he helps guide Flashman and his party across the west to
California.
A character by the Name of Kit Carson also appears in the Time Scout novels by Robert
Asprin. While not identical in origin or time period to the original, the character bears
several similarities, most notably the scouting profession.
There is a Welsh novel, I Ble Aeth Haul Y Bore by Eirug Wyn, which focuses on the Great
Walk, and Kit Carson is one of the main characters. He first helps the Blue Coats to
persuade the Navajos to move from De Chelley, but then he realizes his mistake and then
helps them to overcome a particularly evil sergeant called Dicks.
In Willa Cather's novel Death Comes for the Archbishop, Kit Carson's multifaceted
legend is explored, first as compassionate friend to the natives, later as
"misguided" soldier.
William Saroyan's Pulitzer winning play "The Time of Your Life" includes a
colorful character, an old man, based on the image and reputation of Kit Carson.
Photograph hand oil tinted by artist Margaret A. Rogers
Important Note:
The author of this message may not be subscribed to this list. If you would like to reply
to them, please click on the Message Board URL link above and respond on the board.