Judy,
Your message in the Digest indicates you are decended from REYNOLDS GEORGE
CARNAHAN. I am decended from this line also. However, my line comes down from
William R. CARNAHAN (b. 1851), cousin to GEORGE REYNOLDS (b.1865).
WILLIAM R. is the son of JOHN B. CARNAHAN (b. 1824) and MARGARET
ROBERTSON/ROBINSON (b. 1830). GEORGE REYNOLDS is the son of WILLIAM CARNAHAN and MARGARET
MCCLUE BINHAM.
JOHN B. and WILLIAM were sons of WILLIAM CARNAHAN (b. 1780) and MARY A BROWN
(b. 1796-1797).
Information I have gleaned from other's sharing gave me the name order for
GEORGE REYNOLD. Please let me know if I'm in error. Can you share information on
this line with me? I will be happy to share more detailed information, if
wanted. Just e-mail me!
Also, Note the dreaded ROBERTSON/ROBINSON confusion, anyone solved it yet?
McIntyre Cemetary adjacent to Cottageville Church of Christ (Cottageville is
north of Charlston, south of Ripley) showns this family and refers to Margaret
Carnahan daughter of Martin & Elizabeth Robertson (married to John B.
Carnahan).
Confusion comes from census refering to this family as Robinson. Also, John
B. death certificate refers to Robinson. Could it have been mistakenly written
Robinson when it should have been Robertson OR the-other-way-around? Any
assist is appreciated!