Hi Kim and Phil,
I played around a bit tonight and here is what I found so far:
Malcolm Raymond Carnahan
b. 29 Mar 1895 - b. record from Indiana Births, 1880-1920 - Huntington Co.,
Indiana
1900 - June 7 - Huntington, Huntington Co., Indiana - ED #79 - pg. 12A -
289/294
Carnahan, DAvid - head - Dec 1848 - 51 - md 21 yrs - Pa
Minnie M. - wife - June 1861 - 38 - md 21 yrs - 4/4 - Ohio-Pa-Ohio
Mable - daughter - Feb 1881 - 19 - s - Ohio
Bruce H. - son - May 1883 - 17 - s - Ohio
Albert H. - son - June 1887 - 12 - s - Ohio
Malcolm R. - son - Mar 1895 - 5 - s - Ind
1910 - Apr. 18 - Huntington, Huntington Co., Indiana - ED #92 - pg. 3A - 63/65
Carnahan, Minnie M. - head - 49 - wd - 4/3 - Ohio-Pa-NJ - dressmaker at home
Malcolm R. - son - 15 - s - Ind-Pa-Ohio - laborer
1920 - Jan. 10 - Detroit, Wayne Co., Michigan - ED #213 - pg. 7B - 122/160
Landis, Wilbur E. - head - 57 - md - Ohio-Pa-Pa - printer
Mabel A. - wife - 50 - md - Ohio-Ohio-Pa
Wilbur E. - son - 14 - s - Ohio-Ohio-Ohio - delivery boy bakery
Carnahan, Malcolm - cousin - 24 - s - Ind-Pa-Ohio - ???? printing co
1930 - Apr. 15 - Farmington, Oakland Co., Michigan - ED #18 - pg. 16A -
316/324
Carnahan, Malcolm - head - 35 - md age 25 - Ind-Ind-Ind - pressman printing
Pauline - wife - 30 - md age 20 - Russia-Russia-Russia - 1908 - naturalized
Albert - son - 8 - s - Michigan
Malcolm Jr. - son - 7 - s - Michigan
Minnie M. - daughter - 5 - s - Michigan
William - son - 4 ?/12 - s - Michigan
Selma L. - daughter - 3 ?/12 -s - Michigan
Virginia - daughter - 1 7/12 - s - Michigan
Then... other bits and pieces.
It looks as if Bruce Howard Carnahan married Mabel Alberta Freck.
Birth of a son is in Indiana Births, 1880-1920
Bruce Carnahan - father Bruce Carnahan - mother Mabel Asberba - b. Huntington
Co., Indiana 31 May 1908
Info. from Indiana Deaths, 1882-1920 indicates that Albert H. Carnahan died
21 Nov. 1907 in Huntington Co., Indiana. Which explaines why Minnie indicates
in the 1910 census that she has lost 1 child.
Death record for Elias David is in Indiana Deaths, 1882-1920 except he is
listed as
D. E. Carnahan - d. 9Jan 1908 in Hunginton Co., Indiana - age 60
So I wonder if he is David Elias rather than Elias David.
Now.. as for the parents of Elias David/David Elias I don't know if this is
any good or not.
But... did find this:
1850 - Aug. 25 - Lower St. Clair, Allegheny Co., Pa - pg. 166 - 790/824
David Carnahan - 46 - wagonmaker
????? - wife - 40 - NY
David - 4 - Pa
The wife's name looks something like ?atiema - sure isn't Charity????
1860 - Temperanceville, Allegheny Co., Pa - July 2 - pg. 523 - 187/198
David Carnahan - 57 - carpenter - Pa
Charity - 47 - NY
David - 12 - Pa
1870 - Temperanceville, Allegheny Co., Pa - Aug. 6 - pg. 750B - 91/99
Carnahan, Charity - 60 - keeping house - NY
Anyway.... what do you think???????
Take care - Emma