Emma -
If you look at my post this morning - you'll see Aaron Carnahan and
Elvira Mitchell. I had a conversation about this line with a descendant of
Aaron about a year ago. If I am remembering right -Aaron lived within 5
miles of Rev. John Carnahan at one time which really confused the matter.
Though I haven't done extensive research on this line - Aaron's marriage to
Elvira Mitchell is in Nicholas Co., Kentucky which would certainly make him
a very likely son of James Carnahan and Jane Freyer. According to my
research, they were the only Carnahans in Nicholas Co., Ky at that time.
Linda
So far I can't find any links between Aaron Carnahan and Elvira
Mitchell
to
Andrew Carnahan and Elizabeth Billingsley. However, I am finding
records
of
James Carnahan and Robert Carnahan in Nicholas Co., Ky which seem to
lead
back
to the Pennsylvania Carnahan's.