In keeping with the purpose of this list, the
following constructive feedback is provided.
Carman Family Trees, Carman Web Space,
Patricia Tidmarsh,
http://patricia.rootsweb.com/carman/carmtree.htm,
downloaded 6 August 1999.
The following corrections are noted:
Hezekiah-5 is not the son of William-4 (John-3, Caleb-2, John-1)
as stated on this web page.
Jacob-4 has not been proven to be a son of Caleb-3 (Caleb-2, John-1)
William Stillwell Carman was not born in 1810 and did not
die in 1890 as stated on this webpage.
There currently is no evidence to support the
placement of the Rev. James Carman as a son of
Caleb-2 Carman as shown on this web page.
Additionally, the Joshua Carman depicted here
as a son of Caleb-2 was not the Baptist Preacher
of Kentucky and Emancipationist. This was a
different Joshua and a different generation.
Nor was this Rev. Joshua a son, of the Rev.
James Carman as this web page could be interpreted.
A complete article on the Rev. Joshua Carman of
Kentucky and Ohio origins can be found at the
Carman Meeting Place Website (documented).
http://home.att.net/~carman_family_history/