I need to apologize first for putting out an inquiry about my Carle line and receiving
responses from several of you and not answering the inquiries. I posted my inquiry on the
23rd of February and my sister died on the 25th and I was out of town a week and just
tonight have sit down to try to catch up on some mail.
Harold Hahn I appreciate your response on the Abraham Carl. I did not have him listed as
a son of Thomas Carl and Catherine. I so far only had two children listed for them and am
glad to get your information. I have had a difficult time researching this family from
New York. Seems like libraries here in New Mexico and Texas seem to find other states to
spend their monies on.
I am listing a little more detail tree of what little Carle line I have. If anyone has
any additions or corrections they will be graciously accepted.
Descendants of Thomas Carle, Jr.
1 Thomas Carle, Jr. 1735 - Born: Abt. 1735
.. +Catherine Duytser 1735 - Born: 1735
..... 2 James Carle, Sr. 1760 - Born: 1760
......... +Marytje "Mary" Rhode
............ 3 Sarah Carle 1781 - Born: June 28, 1781
................ +Unknown Loomis
............ 3 Thomas Carle 1790 - Born: February 23, 1790
............ 3 Johannes "John" Carle 1792 - 1866 Born: July 03, 1792 Died:
August 28, 1866 in Charleston, Montgomery Co, NY Age at death: 74
................ +Lucretia Bade 1792 - 1884 Born: November 08, 1792 in Dutchess, NY Died:
March 01, 1884 in Montgomery Co., NY Age at death: 91
................... 4 Hiram Carle 1812 - 1898 Born: Abt. 1812 Died: February 12, 1898 in
Charleston, Montgomery Co, NY Age at death: 86 est.
................... 4 Juliaette "Julia" Carle 1814 - 1898 Born: Abt.
1814 Died: Aft. 1898 Age at death: 84 est.
....................... +John Smith
................... 4 Maria Carle 1815 - 1898 Born: April 30, 1815 Died: Bef. 1898 Age
at death: 83 est.
................... 4 Mary "Polly" Carle 1818 - 1893 Born: 1818 in Montgomery
Co., NY Died: September 24, 1893 in Montgomery Co., NY Age at death: 75 est.
....................... +Isaac Stagg 1809 - 1892 Born: 1809 in NY Died: December 06, 1892
in Montgomery Co, NY Age at death: 83 est.
................... 4 Eli Carle 1819 - 1884 Born: Abt. 1819 Died: Bef. 1884 Age at
death: 65 est.
................... 4 Freeman Carle 1820 - 1898 Born: Abt. 1820 Died: Bef. 1898 Age at
death: 78 est.
................... 4 James F Carle 1820 - 1854 Born: December 22, 1820 Died: March 13,
1854 Age at death: 33
................... 4 Abraham Carle 1833 - 1898 Born: 1833 in Montgomery Co., NY Died:
Bef. 1898 Age at death: 65 est.
............ 3 James Carle, Jr. 1797 - 1869 Born: January 13, 1797 Died: March 14, 1869
in Charleston, Montgomery Co, NY Age at death: 72
................ +Catharine (Carle) 1796 - 1873 Born: May 08, 1796 Died: August 06, 1873
in Charleston, Montgomery Co, NY Age at death: 77
................... 4 Maria Carle
....................... +Albert Wing
................... 4 Julia Carle
....................... +Unknown Burch
..... 2 David Carle
......... +Janny VanNear
............ 3 John Carle 1789 - Born: Bef. July 12, 1789
............ 3 Thomas Carle 1791 - Born: December 14, 1791
Also would like to thank rcarle for their response but I am afraid that we are not
researching the same Abraham Carle but will watch for your line as I continue my
research.
Woodsie I appreciate you attaching the Thomas Carl tree. I will certainly look into this
information that you sent. Some of it agrees with my data and as usual some does not.
Again thanks to each of you and your responses. Sorry to have been so long in answering.
Mary