Diarmid, Thank you for your very insightful reply. Keith
----- Original Message -----
From: "Diarmid Campbell" <diarmid(a)diarmid.fsnet.co.uk>
To: <CAMPBELL-L(a)rootsweb.com>
Sent: Monday, February 26, 2001 3:11 AM
Subject: Who is a Campbell book
Campbells and Kindred,
Keith Campbell asks about the book "Who is a Campbell" - and is it worth
purchasing?
The short answer is "maybe although not really" - rather a qualified
answer.
The author of this book is a sincere man, Jack Campbell, who in his
retirement decided to write books on light and popular subjects like
barkeeping etc. As a Campbell he thought he could do well with a book on
Campbells since (I imagine) he figured there were more Campbells than
barkies. Jack's background was in writing material for commercial
outfits,
if I remember rightly (I also tried to help him with the book
originally).
He did take the trouble to be in touch with the Clan Campbell historian
in
Scotland who spent a good deal of time working through his book
making
corrections and suggestions. Quite a number of these Jack chose to
ignore,
so the book gives some curious impressions and is NOT a good source
of
factual information as a consequence - much is accurate and some is not -
particularly in terms of emphasis - so if you are new to the facts about
the
clan it is hard to know which to take for granted and what not.
However, and here is the qualification: If you are not so much interested
in facts and good interpretation, this book is, with those reservations,
highly readable, short, spicy and might appeal to those who do not
normally
read much at all. I am sure that it has probably introduced the
subject
of
their heritage to many Campbells who may never get much further in
their
interest - or may. If it is cheap enough and appeals to your taste, it
might entertain some teenagers if you are then able to lead them on to
more
rewarding fields and also discuss the contents with them. But I am
just
glad it was not my first impression of my own heritage. Would I have had
the sense to be put off the author and not the subject?
I remember in art history at school being taught about an Italian artist
of
the 16th century who died as a result of blood poisoning got while
disecting
a camel. I remembered that fact and none other about him - not even
his
name. Jack's book is a bit like that - what sticks in the mind are the
rather irrelevant spicy parts, so those who read it are left with a bit of
a
curious - not to say sordid - view of our heritage. But it seems
that the
point is to sell books, not inform. I like my heritage factual, warts and
all if you like, but not rubbed in the dirt. You can show our failures
with
dignity and still be truthfull, but it doesn't sell like the
National
Enquirer.
Dairmid Campbell
----- Original Message -----
From: kcampbell9 <kcampbell9(a)home.com>
To: <CAMPBELL-L(a)rootsweb.com>
Sent: Sunday, February 25, 2001 10:16 PM
Subject: Campbell Book
> Has anyone read the book "Who is a Campbell"? Is it worth purchasing?
Also
I am still trying to find a connection for Franklin J. Campbell born
9/17/1871 in Halifax, Nova Scotia. He moved to Illinois around 1885-1900,
any connections? Thanks Keith Campbell
>
>
> ==============================
> Visit
Ancestry.com for a FREE 14-Day Trial and enjoy access to the #1
> Source for Family History Online. Go to:
>
http://www.ancestry.com/subscribe/subscribetrial1y.asp?sourcecode=F11HB
>
>
==============================
Ancestry.com Genealogical Databases
http://www.ancestry.com/rd/rwlist2.asp
Search over 2500 databases with one easy query!