Thank you, Marjorie, for your kind offer of help. Several of us on the
list have two areas of conflict in our
information on the John CALDWELL in question.
First, this John CALDWELL is referred to variously as John CALDWELL, John C.
(possibly Cleveland)CALDWELL, and John B. CALDWELL.
Secondly, his birth year is variously listed as 1746, 1750, and 1755.
All agree that he married (1) Dicey MANN (my 4Ggrandparents), and (2) Jane
Neeley WALKER.
This John CALDWELL served in the Revolutionary War (I have read).
If you can share the information provided to the DAR so far on this John
CALDWELL, it might be helpful to us, and perhaps one or more of us will be
able to provide the needed reproof. Knowing what data is being contended
will help all of us to be on the lookout for the correct data in the
contested area.
Since there are a number of persons subscribed to this list who are
descendants of this John, I feel certain I can speak for all of them in
saying that we will greatly appreciate any light you can shed on this matter
for us through your DAR contacts. If you can fulfill both offers made in
your last paragraph below, that would be MOST helpful!
Looking forward to hearing further f rom you about this. Thank you very
much.
Martha Penick LAMKIN, Louisville, KY (born in Green Co. KY- GGgrandaughter
of Nancy Hatcher CALDWELL (< Beverley CALDWELL < John CALDWELL < David
CALDWELL < John CALDWELL)
----- Original Message -----
From: "Marjorie L. Wood" <mlwood(a)eurekanet.com>
To: <caldwell(a)rootsweb.com>
Sent: Friday, March 21, 2008 8:50 PM
Subject: Re: [CALDWELL] Warner: re DAR question
I think I have missed some of the first emails in this discussion but
as a
DAR member I have access to the members only site and I looked up John
Caldwell. There is a number of John Caldwell's (I didn't even enter any
other spelling for Caldwell) The one that was married to first to Dicey
Mann
and second to Jean Neely Walker show that his information needs to be
reproved for anyone new to join on this line. Which means something in the
application and/or documentation is possibly wrong and needs more proof or
it could be that someone else has proven this information for another John
Caldwell. (We had this happen within our local chapter and had to find new
proof)
I can give you the information that is shown on this John Caldwell as far
as
birth, death, residence, children and service, then I can give it to you
if
this is what you are looking to find. If there is another Caldwell that
you
would like to see if they served and have been proven for DAR then I can
check that also.
Marjorie Wood
-----